Market risks are concerning; America’s top 10 firms command $21 trillion in market value. For conservative investors, what constitutes a reasonable P/E ratio? Many of today’s equity funds have concentrated their investors’ holdings in these richly valued stocks, which carry an average P/E of 35.

By Raymond M. Mullaney, CEO
January 8, 2025

The 10 Largest US Companies on January 7, 2025

Symbol Name Market Cap
($ billion)
Revenue
($ billion)
Net Income
($ billion)
P/S P/E FRR FRR v2
GOOGL Alphabet $2,410 $339.9 $94.3 7.09 25.6 61 25
AMZN Amazon $2,393 $620.1 $49.9 3.86 48.0 71 59
AAPL Apple $3,703 $391.0 $93.7 9.47 39.5 79 -53
BRK.A Berkshire Hathaway $973 $453.0 $106.9 2.15 9.1 17 93
AVGO Broadcom $1,108 $51.6 $5.9 21.49 188.0 100 -166
META Meta Platforms $1,591 $156.2 $55.5 10.18 28.6 82 12
MSFT Microsoft $3,181 $254.2 $90.5 12.51 35.1 84 -30
NVDA NVIDIA $3,660 $113.3 $63.1 32.31 58.0 93 24
TSLA Tesla $1,319 $97.2 $12.7 13.58 103.9 95 46
WMT Walmart $734 $673.8 $19.7 1.09 37.3 54 -52
Sum $21,073 $3,150.2 $592.1 6.69 35.59 74 -4
Name Market Cap
($ billion)
Revenue
($ billion)
Net Income
($ billion)
P/S P/E FRR FRR v2
10 Largest Companies
with P/E > 100
$3,697 $323 $10.2 11.45 363.1 94 -47
50 Companies,
Market Cap > $50 Billion,
with Highest P/E Ratios
$1,890 $186.3 $13.9 10.15 135.9 90 -99
1,452 Companies with
Market Cap > $100 Million
and P/E > 100 or Negative
$8,846 $2,709 $310.0 3.26 -28.5 79 -84

Consider this: 50 mega-cap companies sport P/Es above 135, totaling $1.9 trillion in market value. Add to that 1,452 companies with P/Es exceeding 100, many without earnings. Does this represent prudent investment territory?

History offers lessons: During both the 2000-2002 and 2007-2008 market crashes, stocks with the steepest declines typically had the highest P/E ratios beforehand.

The S&P 500’s historical P/E patterns over 50 years are telling: P/Es fell below 10 roughly 15% of the time and exceeded 30 about 15% of the time. The performance difference is stark – when P/Es were below 10, subsequent 3-year returns averaged 42%, versus just 13% when P/Es topped 30. The 5-year return gap was even wider: 81% versus 10%.

At least two major risks loom: Rising interest rates typically pressure stock valuations downward, and recessions historically trigger major declines. ERS helps advisors protect their clients assets and grow them safely. Are you prepared for a major decline? Call ERS for strategies built on data science.